M500's Updates or new amps in future

It is obviously impossible to comment on an amplifier that is not out on the market, yet (i.e. the Sentinel amp). Notwithstanding its qualities, I believe Swiss electronics are a typical gravitational focus, CH Precision and Soulution (+ Goldmund) being two exquisite choices if you look for neutral, transparent sound with control and precision, especially in the bass. I myself run a Soulution 717 in stereo (not just for budget, but mostly space constraints), and I can really recommend it for its dynamics, damping/bass precision, and overall neutrality. In my case, the probably rather similar CH Precision M10 was no option because of the two chassis (PSU + Amp) which I could not have accommodated, space-wise.

@QuadDiffuser and @itoakio while I lack a crystal ball (or any form of insight) I will ask the 2 of you a different question. Have you had an opportunity to listen to the MSB Cascade with the M500’s and if so what where your thoughts? Then have you had a chance to listen to the MSB Cascade with the either the CH or the Solution and did you like it better?

I auditioned the Cascade with several amps and the M205’s paired with the Cascade were a better pairing in my mind, I have since upgraded to the M500’s and they are by FAR a better combination, so my advice is patience.

I can’t say the Sentinel Amp will be better, I can’t say you will enjoy it more, I can’t even say they will work in your space or budget, but I can say that waiting for the MSB team to release what is likely to be a simply amazing product is worth it (IMNHO), if the synergy between the Sentinel DAC and the Sentinel AMP is similar to that of the Cascade and M500 then waiting another 6-8 months is in my opinion absolutely worth it.

@QuadDiffuser, based on your amazing room and setup I suspect the space and budget aren’t your main concern, I am guessing it’s the itch to match the amazing DAC you have that is the driving factor, so my question to you is how long from hearing rumours about the Sentinel DAC until you received it?, and more importantly are you willing to repeat the wait

@Peter.Bomberg No, I have not had an S500 or M500s in for comparison. Nor did I claim to have made a proper side-by-side comparison in my response. The only thing I tried to express to @QuadDiffuser is that should he consider a Soulution 717 power amp (or two in mono), this is a product I can recommend from my own experience. Nothing more, nothing less.
My “philosophy” about building my system was to consider amplification and speakers as core, so that match was the most important one for me. Plus, I wanted to have a “proper“ pre-amplifier in the system for a number of reasons such as quality of the buffer, but also for versatility of connections. So preamp, power amp, and speakers (+subs) are the core which I will hopefully retain for a longer time. Digital sources and DACs, however, from my point of view, are subject to shorter technological cycles, which is why I was looking for synergy, but not maximum integration (e.g., not using the DAC’s volume attenuation instead of a dedicated preamp). I like my MSB DAC, but am aware that I might eventually need to swap it out for something else if the “next big thing” gets invented, whatever that may be.
Also I believe Swiss electronics will withstand the “taste of the season” since they are so neutral and controlled/precise. And they make a nice pairing with my equally neutral Californian speakers.

@itoakio sorry if I came across implying anything, I actually really like the CH and was contemplating them as well, but the synergy was simply better with the MSB pairing.

I am convinced I will end up with a streamer eventually for reasons you mention, however I suspect the Sentinel DAC will be the cornerstone, together with the rest of the analog chain and yes + subs

I am torn on the pre- to be honest but then I run pure digital so I only have a single source. And again my apologies if you took my response as anything but a please sit tight and wait as I believe the result will be worth the delay

@Peter.Bomberg I own both a MSB S500 and a Soulution 717. I have them side by side, they are two totally different animals. And I’ve spent the last 6 months trying to figure out which I prefer.

I would assume the mono pair of each would be similar but more dynamic.

Cascade DAC and Rockport Lyra’s, no pre - I have zero need for more gain, and I switch two sources which the Cascade handles just fine.

I can’t stress this more, the two amps sound so completely different and it’s made me question what “neutral” really means, they both are neutral and so different.

The crazy part is it’s like 50/50 for who prefers which when people come to listen to them.

As for CH, I have a CH phonostage and I love it. I’m curious about their amps but, a pair of M10s is a giant space commitment.

If you want to make a trip to DC you can listen as long as you like.

1 Like

@matthewk only if after we head out for a good dinner and talk about our thoughts.

However I have a confession to make, I am not sure I like 100% neutral, I definitely don’t like flat.

I have a tube system in my office and it’s rich and warm, definitly not neutral but sounds perfect when I am working, I have a MSB system as my main listening system driving Estelon Forza’s using AQ Dragons which is a fantastic system but many would say borderline on clinical or bright or analytical (or whatever term you want to inject) but I love how I can pick up details and placements that I can’t with 99% of the systems I have heard, but it’s probably not 100% neutral either and then add a pair of REL No.31s and I would probably called a heretic in some circles but I love the system!

So someday I hope to take you up on your kind offer, and likewise if you ever venture up to Ottawa, come over!

1 Like

I can obviously only speak to the 717 experience (in my case in conjunction with a 727 preamp and Magico speakers and subs), and I perceive the 717’s neutrality not as skeletal or lifeless. To me it sounds well textured across the frequency range, with detailed, but no harsh treble (I can listen rather loud and for a long time without fatigue), articulate mids, and pronounced, but precise base (esp. when I switch off the subs). If at all, it is voiced slightly bottom up. So it does not sound thin at all, however not thick or muddy in the bass, either.
TAS-368-SOULUTION-94-108-REPRINT.pdf (4,2 MB)
Although I have not heard predecessor generations (701, 710, 711), what Jonathan Valin writes in the attached reprint describing the 717 as “most lifelike solid-state amplifier” resonates in my experience with the product.

I wouldn’t say either of them are flat. The s500 has much more timbre, the reverbs and echos are more present. The Soulution is fast and has insane base control, but I’m not sure that’s 100% a great thing. It’s a really hard thing to explain.

The s500 is more tube like than the 717. The 717 has more dynamics, it’s capable of something like 6,000 watts for a couple of seconds. It’s a really hard comparison. Sort of a Ferrari or Lamborghini thing.

One thing you need to consider is that the 717 may not work in your current redesign of your room. They are very tall, it’s a big box. Also they run VERY HOT. They need ventilation.

I do concur, the 717 is a little odd-shaped if you are used to MSB, d’Agostino or Gryphon shapes (deep flat box). It is more cubic like a single CH box or Pilium Cronus. It is less deep, though, than the first.
And it has indeed a much stronger class A bias than previous versions and runs hot at least to the extent that you cannot touch the cooling fins for long with bare hands.

Thank you for the comparisson.

I had s500 with premier +dd to drive my estelon x diamond SE. It was great but had some digital like brightness and thin like a bit loss of body because of the volume control being digital(i think) And low volume performance was not great.

I then went for Vitus SL 103 pre and SM 025 mono amps with premier as dac only. Now there is more body and holographic soundstage but sound is a bit heavy and i am missing the openness and airyness of msb stack

Now i ordered Palisade and will upgrade to Forza Ultra in the future. I want to use Palisade as a pre amp and vitus monos will be a bit short of power dor forzas.

I wan to know how Soulution 717 acts with direct cascade pre amp? And how does 717 compare to s500 for holographic soundstaegw?

Best

Ahmed

Yeah, I still have to do the first comparison, i.e. taking the 727 preamp out and run the Cascade directly into the 717. Will report whenever I have the time; just haven’t found it, yet.
As regards the second comparison, I can’t help with that since I don’t own an S500.
Nevertheless I just realized that, on this thread, we have mostly discussed the amps in the context of MSB DACs and pre-amps. But I believe the speakers are important, too. In my case, I specifically chose the Soulution amplification (727 pre-amp, 717 stereo power amp) for the known match with the S5 2024 which were the starting point of my system building approach (I just like sealed box speakers, and I also like the looks and rather compact format). So I asked myself: Which power amp (and pre-amp) do I want to go with the S5, and how do I want to connect the pair of S-Subs? (I opted for running them straight out of the 727’s second pair of pre-outs, rather than using MSB’s Pro Sub Isolators from the already amplified signal.)
And in the case of the S5 one probably gets automatically drawn to Pilium (always used by Magico, but too boomy/muddy in the bass in my taste) or Soulution or CH. That is how I got there. And I treated the DAC as upstream equipment which has to provide excellent sound per se, but not for the best synergy with the amps. In my case, it was amps and speaker matching I started with.

It works great without a preamp. I run the 717 straight from my Cascade. I’m a firm believer if you have enough current from your source, a passive volume control and enough gain, inserting a pre-amp will only hurt you. IMHO a preamp is only a crutch for a gain issue elsewhere in your system.

Everything being equal, if the pre-amp is giving you something more pleasing than your source directly then the pre-amp is editorializing the signal in some way, irrespective of if you like the way it sounds. I don’t want this so I avoid it.

Regarding holographic imaging? I’m of the opinion that’s more a room thing that an equipment thing so I’m not sure how to answer. I do not perceive much difference in imaging between the two amps.

2 Likes

John,

I can give a status update with as much detail as I currently have. First, circuit design is done for the first draft. We have heavy duty PCB’s on hand. I have designed and machined the new core metal so we can test those PCB’s without them lighting on fire :slight_smile:

Currently, I am working with Sondreal to design the manufacturing jigs for the rest of the chassis. These are some of the biggest parts to make it through our shop and are pushing the limits of what our machines can handle. I think we made the final breakthroughs in workholding yesterday, so I see no red flags there.

In the last months, we have been developing the cabling for the confluence connection. Without this, we really can’t test the amps. In that regard, things are looking good. We have learned a lot and have materials selected for the first draft. (and no, can’t share details on what we have selected :wink: )

The very next steps are to listen to it. This step has taken a bit longer than I would have hoped, we are quite occupied with launching the Palisade DAC alongside the ever intensive production of Sentinel DAC’s. I spent the last three weeks overhauling our inventory system for these new products and we are all feeling to be in a better place schedule wise.

After we get those first listens, we will need to tweak, alter, and test for a while. Optimize the designs we have and then update and re-order. After proof of concept, we imagine that will be a faster and faster cycle the closer we get.

All in all, I consider this great progress for a project this big. A Sentinel level product simply takes more time on every step of the way. That being said, we should know what we are listening to by the end of the year and hopefully start production first thing next year. That is, of course, if our first draft gets us far enough along the cycle. If the performance isn’t there, we will not bring it to market… simple as that. BUT! We will keep working and pushing until it is, but that can take an unknown amount of time.

All I can say about waiting… is that this will be a one of a kind and completely unique amplifier. It should unlock even more of what the Sentinel has to offer.

3 Likes

@Daniel_Francis May I ask for a Christmas present :slight_smile: Not a finished product but maybe a monthly update.

I am happy to wait (ok I lie but it’s a small white lie), thank you for the update and please keep us posted.

1 Like

I will do what I can. Poke me if you don’t hear anything :smiley:

David Hyman visited for a fun factory tour where we tried to cover topics that others hadn’t had the chance to yet… and we have a sneak peak at the Sentinel Amp circuits in the video. It is just a little, but gives you perhaps a bit more information. It’s a fun watch! Thanks David for taking the time to edit this beast of a tour.

8 Likes

I’ve been watching it for the past half hour. Great video so far.

2 Likes

Great video with lots of nuggets scattered troughout but what really strikes me is at 58:.. when the music starts is the size difference between the Cascade and Sentinel, I have seen pictures and know the dimension but aside by side visual makes it soo much clearer

2 Likes