Hello,
I would like to move my MSB Digital Director (DD) a little farther away from the rest of my audio system.
As I understand it, the DD and Select II are connected using both an AOC cable and an optical cable.
I already have a 10-meter AOC cable.
Would it be okay to use a 10-meter optical cable as well to connect the Select II and DD?
Would this length cause any issues with sound quality or connection stability?
Thank you for your help!
There will be no sound quality loss as the audio is done via the AOC cable.
The toslink cable for control can be problematic at 10m. I was able to get it to work in my office but it’s going to be more sensitive to the cable selected. The cables I have found to work best are the cheapest most generic ones or the AmazonBasic cable.
Since toslink cables are very cheap, what I would personally do is get a couple different of the cheapest ones and test in my system before moving any equipment. If you get the “+” on the display and you don’t see a “C-Link Error” message after a while you are good to go! I wouldn’t spend more than $20 on a toslink cable.
This cable is NOT sending audio. It’s not sending anything 99.8% of the time. It’s only used to send commands when you do something like change inputs or the volume.
1 Like
Thank you very much for your detailed response!
Just to confirm, using a 10-meter AOC cable should not cause any issues, correct?
And as for the Toslink cable, if I use a 10-meter cable and don’t experience any C-Link errors, then it should be perfectly fine to use, right?
I’ve also heard that keeping the Digital Director (DD) physically separated from the rest of the audio system can improve sound quality.
Is there any truth to this? I would really appreciate your thoughts on whether moving the DD farther away from the Select II could provide any sonic benefits.
Thank you again for your help!
A 10-meter AOC cable is fine. It is the longest that I would run an AOC cable. I have found that the standard fiber optic transceivers and separate single mode fiber cables exceed the performance of the AOC cables past 10-meters.
As long as you don’t get C-link errors with the toslink cable you want to use you are good to go. It is only used to configure the director and is off nearly all of the time and has no impact on sound quality whatsoever.
@Dustin_Symanski I think you meant to say keep a toslink short. But reading your response I am curious, I can swap but my 40m fiber runs are all OAC and flawless
AOC cables do work perfectly to any length they manufacture. But jitter starts to increase in AOC cables past about 10-meters because they use Multi Mode fiber. The single mode fiber plus the single mode SFP transceivers don’t really increase their jitter no matter how long the cable run is. So the power savings of an AOC doesn’t translate to better performance, from my experience, past a certain cable length. I estimate that at 10-20 meters the AOC cables will reach performance parity with single mode cables and transceivers. AOC cables will still function perfectly past that length however.
@Dustin_Symanski thanks I am off to buy more networking gear 
So back to transceivers, I have a bunch of 10 and 100G, what makes/models does the Sentinel like?
10G SFP+ single mode running the lowest power transceiver are the best for longer runs than 10-20 meters as of now (as long as the distance you want to run is within their capability). The 10G AOC cables of 10-20 meters or shorter are best because of the large power savings and simple (IE high performance) circuitry. But they begin to suffer at longer distances due to dispersion in the multimode fiber they use. The 100G are probably not SFP+ but are probably QSFP, IE they have four data lanes in each direction instead of one.
I don’t recommend the 25G and 50G sfp+ modules or AOC cables because they start to trade much higher noise for wider bandwidth. This results in lower performance overall, even though they still function just fine.
@Dustin_Symanski good point i have replaced everything <10G gear and most is now evn 100G or higher, but I have just used the data gear for the Cascade, I will switch it over to lower bandwidth as they transmit using 25-50% less power but that brings to wonder is 1G enough bandwidth for the Sentinel DAC to Diretor links?
@Dustin_Symanski , i waa initially using the standard optical SFP+ transceivers with a 25m single mode fiber optic cable between the MSB ProUSB module (connected to the USB output of an Antipodes server) and the ProISL module on Cascade Digital Director.
I have since changed this single mode fiber optic connection between the ProUSB module and Cascade Digital Director to a 25m AOC cable.
Does your guideline of using a maximum length of 10-20m AOC cable for improved performance apply for between ProUSB module & ProISL input on Cascade Digital Director?
Would it be better to use the 25m single mode fiber optic cable with the standard SFP+ transceivers instead of the 25m AOC cable in this case?
Thank you.
At 25-meters the best might be ambiguous. The AOC cables at that length will consume less power, but single mode fiber will have slightly less jitter. You probably won’t be able to tell the difference, or cetain people may prefer the effect of less power consumption vs less jitter. I can’t really give perfect guidance. Just to make a previous point AOC cable will function perfectly at any length they are manufactured at, so you don’t have to worry about any malfunctions, data corruption or any other problems.
For all of our SFP+ based connections I have found that the 10 gigabit AOC cables are much better than the 25 gigabit AOC cables. However the 25 gigabit transceivers do function without problems. The reason is that the 25 gigabit cables trade (unnecessary for our links) bandwidth for noise, so the 25 gigabit cables result in noisier signals.
1 Like
Thank you very much Dustin.
I will just enjoy the music instead of worrying about which cable connection is the theoretical best!

@Dustin_Symanski thank you, as I have loads of options I will go with your recommendation, since I am rebuilding the space